New York Times Water Bottle Blues Mohammed Hanif Article

Mohammed Hanif says all copies of 2008 bestseller 'A Case of Exploding Mangoes', based on Zia, confiscated by ISI

Synopsis

ISI agents allegedly raided the publisher's Karachi office.

Agencies

Hanif's acclaimed 'A Case of Exploding Mangoes' is a parody about the former dictator, who was killed in a plane crash in 1988.

KARACHI: Prominent Pakistani novelist and New York Times columnist Mohammed Hanif on Tuesday said that Pakistani security agents raided the offices of his publisher and confiscated all the copies of his 2008 book about the country's former military dictator Zia-ul-Haq.

The raid took place on Monday in Karachi, the largest city and key port in Pakistan, Hanif said.

Hanif, whose acclaimed 'A Case of Exploding Mangoes' is a parody about the former dictator, killed in a plane crash in 1988, blamed the Pakistani spy agency, the Inter-Services Intelligence or ISI, for the raid.

However, an official at the agency described Hanif's claim as a "cheap attempt to gain popularity by hurling false accusations on a national institution." The official spoke on condition of anonymity under ISI regulations.

The agents who arrived at the publisher's offices identified themselves as being from the ISI, said the author, an air force pilot turned journalist. His Karachi publisher had released the Urdu translation of the novel last October.

"They asked about my book and took all copies of it," he said, adding that he was consulting his lawyer about filing a complaint with the police.

This afternoon some people claiming to be from the ISI barged into my Urdu publisher Maktaba Daniyal offices, confi… https://t.co/Cs702axkMw

— mohammedhanif (@mohammedhanif) 1578328388000

To get lists of booksellers. Last week we received a defamation notice from General Zia's son demanding Rs 1 billio… https://t.co/oU8RwBG7lP

— mohammedhanif (@mohammedhanif) 1578328437000

A Case of Exploding Mangoes has been in publication for 11 years now. Nobody has ever bothered me. Why now? I am s… https://t.co/6AkhBUujBn

— mohammedhanif (@mohammedhanif) 1578328490000

Hanif rose to fame when the novel was first published in 2008 in English, two decades after Haq who was killed when his plane went down in eastern Punjab province. Authorities never released the results of their investigation or say what had caused the crash, which also killed US Ambassador Arnold Raphel and then-ISI chief Gen. Akhtar Abdur Rahman.

Hanif also alleged the raid came after members of his family sent a note to his publisher complaining that the novel tarnished the image of Haq, who seized power in a coup in 1977.

It was unclear his relatives would complain about his work so many years later but Hanif speculated they were unconcerned when it was only available in English but became worried once it was translated, presumably because many more Pakistanis would read it in Urdu.

The book cites a rumour that a bomb had been planted inside a crate of mangoes that were gifted to Haq and that was also aboard the plane.

Pakistan has witnessed an intensified crackdown on human rights defenders, activists, journalists and members of civil society over the past years.

Agencies

Zia-ul-Haq was killed when his plane went down in eastern Punjab province. Authorities never released the results of their investigation or say what had caused the crash. (Image: TOI)

Journalists, who have taken on military dictators and been beaten and jailed in the pursuit of a free press, say they now face a form of censorship that is more subtle but no less chilling, spearheaded by the security services and the ISI, to quash critical coverage.

Judging A Book By Its Cover: Authors Who Stirred A Storm

Freshly Brewed Controversy

The Bombay High Court has restrained industrialist Vijaypat Singhania from releasing his tell-all memoir. Here are other tomes that took a page out of controversy's book.

Plagiarism Plague

In June 2012, American rapper Jay-Z (in pic) was sued by writer Patrick White. The latter claimed that large parts of the musician's 2010 autobiography, Decoded, was a product of plagiarism. White claimed that his laptop was stolen in 2009, a year before the book was published, and that the book contained "expressions/colours/ phrases" that co-related to his work. In fact, the book was a collection of Jay-Z's songs and the story behind how each one was made.

(Image: AFP)

Fallen Cyclist

After Lance Armstrong (in pic) confessed to using performance-enhancing drugs, two of his fans sued him in January 2013 for lying in his two memoirs — It's Not About the Bike (2000) and Every Second Counts (2003). Rob Stutzman and Jonathan Wheeler said they wouldn't have bought the books if they knew they were works of fiction.

A Fictional Saga

American author Augusten Burroughs (in pic) was sued by his foster family, the Turcottes, for defaming them in his 2002 memoir Running with Scissors. In his book, Burroughs describes his life after his chainsmoking mother asked her psychiatrist Dr Rodolph Turcotte to be his legal guardian so that he could attend school in Northampton, Massachusetts. The Turcottes filed a suit against him in 2005 claiming large parts of the book were untrue. These included the family condoning affairs between adults and children and keeping an electroshock machine hidden under the stairs. Burroughs settled the suit in 2007. The book was then classified as fiction instead of a memoir.

Striking A Chord

Celebrated English concert pianist James Rhodes (in pic) had to fight his ex-wife in court to publish his 2015 autobiography, Instrumental: A Memoir of Madness, Medication and Music. She filed an injunction in court in October 2014 that sought to stop publication on the grounds that it would psychologically harm their 12-year-old son who had been detected with Asperger's Syndrome. The book gave details of sexual abuse that the pianist had faced as a child. In May 2015, the court overturned the injunction, clearing the path for the publication of the book.

Jul 15, 2022, 05:09 AM IST

Experience Your Economic Times Newspaper, The Digital Way!

• Front Page
• Pure Politics
• ET Markets
• Smart Investing
• More

• /home_printedition.cms?msid=92885743&lazy=show

Read More News on

Download The Economic Times News App to get Daily Market Updates & Live Business News.

...more less

huskeyraimmake.blogspot.com

Source: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/magazines/panache/mohammed-hanif-says-all-copies-of-2008-bestseller-a-case-of-exploding-mangoes-based-on-zia-confiscated-by-isi/articleshow/73138583.cms

Share this post